2017 All-SCAC
| Brett Taff | Third Base | So. | 1st Team |
| Gus Daniel | Catcher | Sr. | 2nd Team |
| Austin Dudley | Shortstop | Jr. | Honorable Mention |
| Scott Gelbart | First Base | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Chance Hatchel | Designated Hitter | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Josh Lewis | Pitcher | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
2016 All-SCAC
| Oscar Gonzalez | Outfield | Fr. | Honorable Mention |
2015 All-SCAC
| Brett Moody | Pitcher | So. | 2nd Team |
| Gus Daniel | Catcher | So. | Honorable Mention |
2014 All-SCAC
| Gus Daniel | Catcher | Fr. | 1st Team |
2013 All-SCAC
| Tyler Appelquist | First Base | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Austin Vaughan | Outfield | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Travis Gibson | Outfield | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Marshall Korn | Pitcher | So. | Honorable Mention |
2012 All-SCAC
| Tyler Appelquist | First Base | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Chase Muder | Catcher | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| John Schulmeister | Outfield | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
2011 All-SCAC
| Scooter Merritt | Outfield | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Brian Buehler | First Base | Jr. | Honorable Mention |
| Mason Leech | Third Base | Jr. | Honorable Mention |
| Tyler Steed | Pitcher | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
2010 All-SCAC
| Brian Buehler | First Base | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Andy White | Shortstop | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Scooter Merritt | Second Base | Jr. | Honorable Mention |
2009 All-SCAC
| Patrick Ray | Catcher | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Bennett Herrick | Third Base | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Bobby Schleizer | First Base | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
2008 All-SCAC
| Andy White | Shortstop | So. | 1st Team |
| Bennett Herrick | Third Base | So. | Honorable Mention |
| Bobby Schleizer | First Base | Jr. | Honorable Mention |
2007 All-SCAC
SCAC Champions / Carl Iwasaki, Coach of the Year
| Patrick Ray | Catcher | So. | 1st Team |
| Matt Finke | Second Base | So. | 1st Team |
| John Reisig | Outfield | Fr. | 1st Team |
| Scooter Means | Designated Hitter | So. | 1st Team |
| Will Chermak | Pitcher | Fr. | Honorable Mention |
| Clint Rushing | Pitcher | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Andy White | Shortstop | Fr. | Honorable Mention |